Recent Reviews

Scott Pilgrim vs. The World

reviewed by Martin Lewis

03 September 2010

For the first fifteen minutes I couldn't see how someone who had read the comics could enjoy the film. After that I found myself smiling and then laughing and enjoying the film on its own terms. But then, for the final fifteen minutes, I once again found the schism between the film and the comics too hard to overcome.

The Way of Kings by Brandon Sanderson

reviewed by Niall Alexander

01 September 2010

From its multiple prologues and preludes through to its calm-before-the-storm last chapter and indeed beyond, The Way of Kings is all about beginning.

Narrative Power: Encounters, Celebrations, Struggles, edited by L. Timmel Duchamp

reviewed by Anil Menon

30 August 2010

The volume's subtitle—Encounters, Celebrations, Struggles—explains why its essays linger in the mind. Its writers have skin in the game.

The Red Tree by Caitlin R. Kiernan

reviewed by Audrey Homan

27 August 2010

I confess: the first time I read this book, I couldn't stand it. The second time I fell in love with it, and now I'm thinking of buying a backup copy in case my house burns down.

Toy Story 3

reviewed by David J. Schwartz

25 August 2010

For a film that is ostensibly for children, Toy Story 3 has already accumulated a wide range of analyses.

Above the Snowline by Steph Swainston

reviewed by Niall Harrison

23 August 2010

Above the Snowline is, by some way, Steph Swainston's least epic, most intrigue-driven novel.

Shine edited by Jetse de Vries

reviewed by Karen Burnham

20 August 2010

Dismayed by the amount of dystopian SF on the market, de Vries aims to showcase SF that depicts futures better than what we have now. I find myself sympathetic to his goal: since time immemorial, humans have complained that the world is going to hell in a handbasket, that the Golden Age or Age of Heroes is behind us, that we've diminished in some fundamental way. And yet somehow the years go by, standards of living go up, life spans increase, and we beat out Malthus again and again.

Mammoths of the Great Plains and Tomb of the Fathers by Eleanor Arnason

reviewed by Kelly Jennings

18 August 2010

Too often we are assured that we have no alternatives. Democracy is the worst form of government except for all the other forms. Capitalism is an unequal distribution of wealth, while communism is an equal distribution of poverty. The way it was in my dad's house in the suburbs is the way it ought to be forever. Much of contemporary science fiction, far from interrogating these assumptions, endorses them.

Red Plenty by Francis Spufford

reviewed by Adam Roberts

16 August 2010

I exhort you, comrades!—to read this book.

X6 edited by Keith Stevenson

reviewed by Richard Larson

13 August 2010

The novella is an interesting form, or at least an interesting length.

Inception

reviewed by William Mingin

11 August 2010

If this were just a fantasy action thriller it would be a standout, hard-driving and complex, consistently entertaining. But it's not just a kinetic series of exciting or fantastic images, a hyperactive body, if you will; it has a head and a heart.

A Dark Matter by Peter Straub

reviewed by Jonathan McCalmont

09 August 2010

A Dark Matter addresses one of the fundamental problems of personal identity.

Pinion by Jay Lake

reviewed by Paul Kincaid

06 August 2010

The whole trilogy can be seen as an exercise in avoiding the issues raised by the world Lake has created.

Archived Reviews

View older reviews in our Archive, thanks to the kindness of our authors who allow us to keep their material online.